Rich, boozy, fudgy, and chewy, these Irish coffee brownies are an indulgent treat for the adults. Great for a St. Patrick’s Day party, these brownies can be enjoyed any time of the year. While they’re meant as a boozy treat, and the alcohol does cook out, you can make a few tweaks to be alcohol-free as well.
Take out the cream cheese so it can start to soften while you gather the rest of the ingredients. Make a foil or parchment paper sling for a 13x9 baking pan and set aside. Preheat your oven to 350°F / 180°C.
In a medium mixing bowl add 1 ¾ cups flour and 1 teaspoon table salt and whisk together. Set aside.
In a large, heat proof mixing bowl add ⅓ cup Dutch cocoa powder and 2 teaspoons espresso powder and set aside. Chop 2oz unsweetened baking chocolate into small pieces and set aside. Add ½ cup Irish whiskey to a small pot and bring to a boil over high heat.
Working quickly, pour the boiling whiskey over the cocoa and espresso powder and stir with a spoon until fully incorporated. Add the chopped-up chocolate and keep stirring until fully melted and you should have a thick, chocolate base. Set aside to cool slightly for a few minutes.
Melt 3 tablespoons unsalted butter in a microwave safe container, then add the melted butter, ½ cup vegetable oil, and 2 teaspoons vanilla extract to the chocolate base, stirring until fully combined. Add 2 cups white sugar and ½ cup dark brown sugar and stir until there’s no dry clumps of sugar remaining and everything looks grainy, but mostly smooth. Now add the 2 eggs and 2 egg yolks, one at a time, until everything is smooth again.
Add the flour and salt mixture to the brownie base in 2-3 batches, stirring until no pockets of dry flour remain and you have a thick brownie batter. Butter or spray the foil or parchment sling with cooking spray. Reserve about ¾ a cup of batter and pour the rest into the prepared 13x9 baking pan. Use a spoon or spatula to spread out the batter into an even layer that reaches all the sides and corners of the baking pan.
Now make the cream cheese portion. Wipe out any remaining flour from the mixing bowl you used before and add the softened 8oz of cream cheese. Cutting it into smaller pieces will make mixing easier. Using a hand mixer on low speed, break up the cream cheese until fluffy and smooth.
Add the ¼ cup Bailey’s and ¼ cup white sugar and mix on low speed, increasing the speed as it mixes into the cream cheese. Now add the egg yolk and continue mixing until everything is smooth and creamy looking. If using the mini chocolate chips, add them now and fold into the cream cheese mix with a spatula.
Scoop large portions of the cream cheese mix and set on top of the brownie batter in the baking pan in random portions that aren’t touching. Now add the reserved brownie batter to the top of the cream cheese scoops. Using a butter knife or something similar, make vertical and horizontal swirls through the entire pan to create a swirled, marbled effect with the cream cheese.
Place the baking dish into the middle of the oven and bake for 30-40 minutes. Start checking at the 30-minute mark. A toothpick should come out slightly moist with a few crumbs attached. Mine took about 36 minutes. When finished cooking, remove from the oven and allow to cool for 5-10 minutes in the pan, then lift the sling out gently and set the brownies on a cooling rack until fully cooled and set.
Use a sharp knife to cut into 24 brownies and serve.
1) Non-Alcoholic – These brownies are meant to be made with alcohol, but if you need to make them alcohol-free or are worried about kids eating them with liquor, you can make two small tweaks. Change the Irish whiskey to just water, and replace the Bailey’s with an Irish cream coffee creamer. Substituting with just water will make the final brownies chewier than the original recipe, but the flavor should still be fine.2) Baking Pan – As stated earlier, these brownies are meant to be shared so the recipe uses a 13x9 pan and makes 24 brownies. A normal brownie pan is usually an 11x7 baking pan, but I try to avoid asking people to use a specific sized pan they may not own. If you’d prefer to make a smaller batch, you could make the full recipe and freeze half the uncut brownies as mentioned in how to store, or you could try making half the recipe in an 8x8 pan for 9 brownies instead. I haven’t tested this personally but leave a comment if you do.3) Vanilla Extract – As mentioned in the ingredient portion of the post, a bourbon vanilla goes great here as it enhances the whiskey flavor better than a vodka-based vanilla would, but any vanilla extract is fine. If you’ve never tried it, homemade vanilla extract is great and easy to make, and I used my own homemade bourbon vanilla here.4) Green Dye – This is optional, but I have added some green food coloring to the cream cheese swirl in the past for St. Patrick’s Day with these brownies. Generally, I don’t add that though. While it can add some festive color to the brownies, I also find it to be slightly confusing. As the saying goes, “you eat with your eyes,” and a lot of people associate a green color in brownies to be mint flavored, so when it tastes like Irish cream and not mint, it can feel confusing. Feel free to use it though if you like the pop of color.